Jasper Smith

Commentary on politics, economics, culture and sports.

Ezra on Obama

leave a comment »

Ezra articulates his disappointment with the candidacy of Barrack Obama. Not surprisingly, given the fact that Ezra is the progressive blogosphere’s eminence grise on matters related to healthcare,  he focuses on Senator Obama’s dismal healthcare plan:

I understand that he needs to defend his plan, but he’s making an argument that, I imagine, future Republicans will quote back at progressive reformers. To me, this is worse than the Social Security stuff. At least there, he’s advocating a progressive policy, if buying into a Republican frame. Here, he’s constructing a conservative frame to defend a bad policy, a policy I believe his campaign regards as a mistake. He talks a lot about honesty. He should be honest. The lack of a mandate was a mistake, born out of caution, and he should rectify it. Hell, he’s already said that, if he could go back to the country’s beginning, he’d choose single-payer. So if he doesn’t want to turn and mimic Clinton’s position, and if he instead wants to say that having thought it through, the individual mandate is the wrong way to guarantee universality, and we should simply make insurance a right, guaranteed by the government because that’s what sort of country we are, and he’s sorry for letting consultants constrain him, that would be great. But to see Obama, day after day, argue against collective action and universality, is deeply disappointing, almost heartbreaking. He had the capacity to elevate those ideals, to do for them what Reagan did for individualism. He’s letting that opportunity, that potential, slip away.

Preach it, Ezra.

A progressive economic agenda happens to be my biggest priority in 2008. It’s not my only priority. But it is number one. It’s too bad that Obama isn’t as strong as he could be in this department, because his candidacy has a lot to offer the country. But I’m tired of mucking about: The tea leaves strongly favor a Democrat in 2008, and I want to make sure the Democrat taking the oath shares my priorities. If he’s still viable when the Massachusetts primary comes around, I’ll strongly consider John Edwards. But as of right now, I’m a Clinton supporter. Should Obama heed Ezra’s advice and publicly resharpen some of his domestic policy plans (especially on healthcare), I may reconsider. Heaven forbid a politician change his mind about something he’s plainly wrong about, so that he can now be right.

By the way, Hillary Clinton’s plan, which, we all acknowledge, was basically right out of Edwards’s playbook (with one or two improvements), was politically very astutely written and presented. My own take on the Hillarycare fiasco of 1993 is that its biggest flaw was that it didn’t get the politics of healthcare right. So, her efforts this time around tell me that she has learned from her mistakes, and that having failed the first time around, Hillary Clinton is — as she claims, and contrary to her critics — more, not less, likely to succeed in giving every American meaningful healthcare coverage.

We are correct in avoiding people who make the same mistake again and again. But people who learn from their mistakes are usually some of the most effective people on offer.


Written by Jasper

November 26, 2007 at 5:58 pm

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: